Flexo vs. Litho vs. Digital: The different types of print that are commonly used within the packaging
Flexo vs Litho
vs Digital: Printing
Methods Compared
Choosing the right printing method is crucial for the quality of your packaging. Flexographic (Flexo), Lithographic (Litho), and Digital printing methods each offer unique advantages and are suited to different needs. Understanding the materials used, the costs involved, and the volume fulfilment of each method can significantly influence your decision-making process.
In this guide, we’ll provide a comprehensive comparison of these printing techniques, helping you to make an informed choice that balances performance with cost efficiency. By considering these factors, businesses can enhance their packaging, align with sustainability goals, and meet market demands effectively.
Flexographic Printing (Flexo Print)
Flexographic printing, commonly known as Flexo, is a versatile and widely used method in the packaging industry. It involves using flexible relief plates, typically made of rubber or photopolymer, to transfer ink onto various substrates, including paper, plastic, metallic films, and cellophane. The process starts with creating a master plate that has the desired image or text in relief. Ink is then applied to the raised areas of the plate, which is subsequently pressed against the substrate to create the print.
Flexo stands out for its ability to print on a wide range of materials, including non-porous surfaces, making it ideal for packaging. Compared to Litho and Digital printing, Flexo is known for its high-speed production capabilities and cost-effectiveness for large runs. Its quick-drying inks, often water-based, contribute to faster turnaround times. Flexo is particularly advantageous for printing continuous patterns, such as those used in packaging films and labels.
What Is Flexo Printing Commonly Used For?
Flexo printing is a versatile and efficient printing method, commonly used for a variety of packaging and labelling applications:
-
Flexible Stand-Up Pouches: Ideal for food and beverage products, Flexo printing provides high-quality, durable prints on flexible packaging materials.
-
Labels: Frequently used for product labels, Flexo printing ensures sharp images and text on various label materials, including paper and synthetic substrates.
-
Mailing Bags: Used for printing on mailing bags, Flexo offers quick and cost-effective solutions for shipping and logistics companies.
-
Corrugated Boxes: Perfect for printing on corrugated cardboard, Flexo delivers consistent and high-quality prints for shipping and retail packaging.
These applications highlight Flexo Printing’s ability to handle diverse materials and produce high-quality results.
Flexographic Printing: Pros and Cons
Benefits:
-
High-speed production, ideal for large print runs: Ensures large quantities are printed quickly, meeting tight deadlines and reducing lead times.
-
Capable of printing on a wide range of substrates: Versatile for various materials like paper, plastic, metallic films, and cellophane, catering to diverse packaging needs.
-
Cost-effective for long runs: Initial setup costs are spread over large volumes, reducing per-unit cost, ideal for bulk printing.
-
Uses quick-drying inks, often water-based: Speeds up production and supports environmental sustainability with reduced volatile organic compounds (VOCs).
-
Efficient for continuous patterns and large areas of solid colour: Provides consistent, high-quality results for packaging films and labels with seamless designs.
-
Eco-friendly ink options available: Offers sustainable inks like water-based or UV-curable options, reducing environmental impact.
Drawbacks
-
Initial setup costs can be high: Custom plate creation is expensive, posing a barrier for small print runs or limited budgets.
-
Less suitable for very detailed or high-resolution prints: Limited in achieving fine details compared to digital printing.
-
Colour consistency can be challenging to maintain: Requires careful monitoring to avoid variations in ink viscosity, substrate, and speed.
-
Limited flexibility for last-minute design changes: Time-consuming and costly to make changes once plates are created.
-
Plate creation time can be lengthy: Delays the start of the printing process, impacting quick turnaround times.
-
Requires skilled operators for optimal results: Skilled operators are essential to manage the equipment and materials effectively, necessitating training and experience.
Lithographic Printing (Litho Print)
Lithographic printing, commonly known as Litho, is a method based on the principle that oil and water do not mix. The process involves creating an image on a flat metal plate, usually aluminium, where the image areas are treated to attract ink while the non-image areas repel ink. The plate is first moistened with water, which adheres to the non-image areas. Ink is then applied, adhering only to the image areas. The inked image is transferred from the plate to a rubber blanket and then to the printing surface, typically paper.
Litho printing is renowned for its ability to produce high-quality, sharp images and text, making it ideal for detailed artwork and photographic reproduction. It differs from Flexo in that it is more suited for high-resolution prints and from Digital printing in that it is more cost-effective for medium to large print runs once the initial setup is complete. Litho is particularly effective for producing consistent, high-quality prints across large volumes.
What Is Litho Printing Commonly Used For?
Litho printing is commonly used for a variety of packaging applications due to its high-quality output and cost-effectiveness for medium to large print runs:
-
Rigid Presentation Boxes: Litho printing provides excellent detail and colour consistency, making it ideal for luxury packaging such as rigid presentation boxes. These boxes often require high-resolution images and fine detail to enhance their premium appeal.
-
Corrugated Boxes: For high-quality graphics on corrugated boxes, Litho printing is a preferred choice. A litho sheet is adhered to the corrugated box, delivering sharp images and vibrant colours, and making these boxes visually appealing and suitable for retail packaging.
-
Carton Board: Litho printing is commonly used for printing on carton board, which is used in a wide range of packaging applications, including food and beverage, pharmaceuticals, and cosmetics. It ensures high-quality prints that are essential for brand recognition and product presentation.
These applications highlight Litho printing's capability to produce high-quality, detailed images and consistent results across various packaging materials. Its precision and ability to deliver vibrant colours make it a preferred choice for premium and retail packaging solutions.
Litho Printing: Pros and Cons
Benefits:
-
High-quality, detailed prints: Produces sharp images and text, ideal for detailed artwork and photographic reproduction, ensuring premium visual appeal.
-
Consistent colour and quality: Maintains consistent colour and quality across large print runs, essential for brand consistency and professional presentation.
-
Cost-effective for medium to large runs: Becomes more economical with larger print volumes, making it a good choice for medium to large print runs.
-
Suitable for various substrates: Can be used on a wide range of materials, including paper, cardboard, and some plastics, offering versatility for different packaging needs.
-
High-speed production for large volumes: Efficiently handles large print volumes, making it suitable for mass production of packaging materials.
Drawbacks:
-
Longer setup time: Time-consuming setup due to plate creation and precise alignment, potentially delaying urgent projects.
-
Limited flexibility for design changes: Can be difficult to make design changes once plates are created, which can be a disadvantage for projects requiring frequent updates.
-
Environmental concerns: Traditional processes involve chemicals and solvents, impacting the environment, though more sustainable practices are being developed.
-
Requires skilled operators: Best results require skilled operators, with training and experience essential to manage the equipment and materials effectively.
Digital Printing
Digital printing is a modern method that directly transfers digital images onto various substrates using inkjet or laser printers. Unlike traditional printing methods, digital printing does not require printing plates. Instead, it uses electronic files and prints directly from digital sources. This process involves the deposition of ink or toner on the substrate, which is then cured or set by heat or UV light.
Digital printing methods, including inkjet and xerography, account for approximately 15% of the total volume of print in the world. The printers you have at home typically rely on digital printing, using toners and cartridges rather than plates.
Inkjet Printing: Inkjet printers produce images by propelling diminutive drops of ink out of print heads. They can print on a wide variety of substrates, such as paper, plastic, canvas, or even floor tiles. Inkjet devices are most commonly used for printing signage, posters, books, and photo books. A significant benefit of inkjet printing is the ability to print variable data, such as mailing addresses or coupon codes, which cannot be achieved through flexographic printing. This makes inkjet printing favourable for shorter-run projects without the need for printing plates or origination costs. Sometimes, a combination of flexographic and digital print is used depending on the project type.
Xerography: Xerographic printers, such as laser printers, create images by selectively applying a charge to a metal cylinder known as a drum. The electrical charge attracts toner particles, which then adhere to the medium being printed on. To ensure the toner has properly adhered to the substrate, it passes through a fuser that melts the toner into the medium. This process, originally developed by Hungarian physicist Pál Selényi in 1942, led to the development of the Xerox 914, the first commercial automatic copier.
Digital printing is highly flexible and efficient, making it ideal for short runs and custom projects. It allows for quick turnaround times and is perfect for on-demand printing. One of its significant advantages is the ability to easily make changes or updates to the design without the need for costly and time-consuming plate creation. Digital printing also supports variable data printing, enabling personalised packaging solutions.
Compared to Flexo and Litho printing, digital printing offers superior flexibility and is particularly advantageous for small to medium print runs, as well as projects requiring high levels of customisation.
What Is Digital Printing Commonly Used For?
Digital printing is commonly used for a variety of packaging applications due to its flexibility and efficiency. Here are some typical uses:
-
Flexible Stand-Up Pouches: Digital printing allows for high-quality, custom designs on flexible packaging materials, making it ideal for products that require vibrant and detailed graphics.
-
Labels: Perfect for short runs and customisation, digital printing is often used for product labels, offering the ability to produce variable data printing for personalised and targeted marketing.
-
Carton Board: Digital printing is used for printing on carton board, suitable for packaging in various industries including food, beverages, cosmetics, and pharmaceuticals. It ensures high-quality prints and allows for quick changes in design.
Digital Printing: Pros and Cons
Benefits:
-
Quick turnaround times: Eliminates the need for plate creation, allowing faster production and delivery, ideal for on-demand printing and meeting tight deadlines.
-
High level of customisation: Supports variable data printing, enabling personalised and highly customised packaging solutions, useful for targeted marketing campaigns.
-
No need for plates: Reduces setup costs and allows easy design changes and updates without additional expenses.
-
Eco-friendly options: Uses less waste and fewer chemicals, supporting the use of eco-friendly inks and substrates for sustainable practices.
-
Ideal for short to medium runs: Cost-effective for short to medium print runs, making it excellent for small businesses and limited edition packaging.
Drawbacks:
-
Higher cost per unit for large runs: More expensive per unit for large print volumes compared to traditional methods like Flexo and Litho.
-
Limited substrate compatibility: Not always compatible with all types of substrates, especially some specialised materials, limiting its application range.
-
Quality variation: Variations in print quality can occur, particularly for very high-resolution or colour-critical jobs.
-
Slower printing speed for large volumes: Slower than traditional methods for large print volumes, affecting production efficiency for bulk orders.
-
Potential for lower durability: Depending on the substrate and ink used, digital prints can sometimes be less durable than those produced by traditional methods, impacting suitability for certain packaging applications.
Cost Considerations
Cost considerations are crucial when choosing a printing method for packaging, as they can significantly impact the overall budget:
Flexo Printing
Litho Printing
Digital Printing
Setup Costs
Initial setup requires the creation of custom plates. Justified for large print runs as costs are amortised over a large volume (typically 1000 units), reducing the per-unit cost.
Moderate setup costs. Creating plates is necessary but generally cheaper than Flexo. Ideal for medium to large print runs.
Low setup costs. No need for plates, making it economical for short runs and on-demand printing. Design changes are easy and inexpensive.
Production Costs
Cost-effective for large volumes due to high-speed production capabilities. The more you print, the cheaper the per-unit cost becomes.
Cost-effective for medium to large volumes. Consistent quality and efficiency make it suitable for large batches, with per-unit costs decreasing as volume increases.
Higher per-unit costs for large volumes compared to Flexo and Litho. More cost-effective for short to medium runs and highly customised projects.
Material Costs
Moderate material costs. Flexo can print on a wide range of substrates, which can vary in cost.
Generally higher material costs due to the need for high-quality substrates to maintain print quality.
Can be higher due to the specific substrates and inks used. However, the flexibility in substrate choice can also lead to cost savings depending on the material selected.
To summarise: Flexo printing is more cost effective for large volumes. Litho printing offers a balance for medium to large runs with high-quality output. Digital printing is ideal for short runs and customised projects with minimal setup costs.
Sustainability Considerations
Sustainability is a critical factor in the modern packaging industry, with increasing demand for eco-friendly solutions:
Flexo Printing
Litho Printing
Digital Printing
Waste and Efficiency
Generates waste during setup due to plate creation. Technological advancements have reduced waste and improved efficiency.
Produces significant waste during plate creation and setup. Recent advancements have improved efficiency and reduced waste.
Minimal waste due to no plates and setup waste is virtually eliminated. On-demand printing reduces overproduction and waste.
Energy Consumption
Generally energy-efficient. Modern presses have integrated energy-saving features
Requires energy for plate-making and printing processes.
Can be energy-intensive. Benefits from advancements in energy-efficient technologies and practices.
Chemical Usage
Reduced due to the use of water-based inks and UV-curing.
Traditional processes involve chemicals in plate-making. Efforts are ongoing to develop eco-friendly alternatives.
Minimal chemical usage due to digital processes.
To summarise: Flexo printing is known for using energy-efficient presses, though it can generate waste during setup. Litho printing involves chemical usage and waste during plate creation. Digital printing minimises waste but it can be energy-intensive. Each printing method has its own sustainability strengths and weaknesses, but ongoing technological advancements are making all three options more environmentally friendly. For instance, all inks are sustainable these days, making each method an eco-friendly choice.
Explore Printing Options at Sarcina Packaging
Choosing the right printing method for your packaging needs involves balancing quality, cost, and sustainability. Flexo, Litho, and Digital printing each offer unique benefits and are suited to different applications.
Explore the diverse printing options available from Sarcina Packaging to find the perfect solution for your packaging requirements. For more information or to get a quote,
contact our team using the form below.